PDA

View Full Version : Oct. 10, 2007: No search needed for YMCA director



Record-Journal
10-10-2007, 01:31 AM
MERIDEN — Bruce Miller has retired as executive director of the Meriden YMCA. His replacement, John Benigni, a 15-year employee, served his first day as executive director Tuesday.

Miller will remain involved with the YMCA for the next few months. “So it isn’t like I’m going away,” he said.

Miller spent 32 years in the organization, the last 18 with the Meriden YMCA, and was eligible to retire after 30 years.

He said he’d been thinking about retiring since he’d reached the eligibility mark.

“Change is good for the individual, meaning me, and change is good for the organization,” said Miller, 56.

In June, Miller notified the Meriden YMCA executive board of his intent to retire. He’d wanted to wait for the completion of a major project, the child care center on Crown Street, before stepping down.

Benigni, 32, has been a full-time employee for the past nine years in a number of positions. Most recently, he was membership and program director. A 1993 graduate of Platt High School, Benigni has a degree in sociology from Central Connecticut State University.

“I’m honored that the board has entrusted me to be director of the Meriden YMCA,” Benigni said.

The YMCA’s 22-member board of directors chose not to conduct a nationwide search for Miller’s replacement, and voted on Thursday to offer the position to Benigni.

A national search would have cost the organization $15,000, according to Jackie Fordiani, board president. “We’d rather spend that in serving the citizens of Meriden,” she said.

“I based my decision on the savings from the search and my confidence in John,” Fordiani said. “I believe that he will be able to keep us going.”

The local YMCA contends with its fair share of the financial challenges faced by nonprofit organizations.
“The biggest challenges are the same as they always are,” said Miller, “to move from fiscal stability to fiscal health.”

Miller was earning $104,000 a year, with benefits and a pension. With his retirement, the organization could save up to $70,000 annually, Fordiani said.

Benigni was earning about $40,000 annually. The board is still putting together the terms of Benigni’s employment and salary as executive director, said Fordiani, and has not made him a salary offer yet.

But Benigni is “confident they’re going to be fair,” Miller said.

The YMCA has an overall membership of about 4,000, an exponential growth from when Miller started as executive director in 1989.

He had come to Meriden from the Westbrook YMCA. Today, there are 14 full-time positions in the Meriden organization, and 200 employees.

Benigni is the brother of Meriden’s mayor, Mark D. Benigni, who also has a long-term close relationship with Miller.

Miller hired Mark Benigni as a youth sports director shortly after Miller came to Meriden, and the mayor, now an assistant principal of Berlin High School, credited Miller with allowing him to create new programs “and give it a shot.”

“Bruce hired me years ago, to work for the YMCA, and I hired John, so it’s sort of come full circle,” the mayor said.

Miller was ready for a new challenge, Mark Benigni said. “I’m also really excited for my brother, who grew up with the YMCA in his blood.”

In some respects, the leadership transition at the YMCA mirrors that of the Meriden Boys & Girls Club a couple of years ago.

When the club’s longtime executive director, Gary “Tex” Burt, retired, his replacement was a young man who’d grown up in Meriden and had extensive work experience in the organization.

“I think it’s important for a leader to have had their hands in an organization in many areas,” said Donald Maleto, who took over from Burt as executive director in January 2006. “And, obviously, John’s been there a long time, so he understands how to run the place.”

“I think you get a benefit,” Mark Benigni said. “With John you get somebody who grew up with the organization and the community.”

Miller has no plans to leave Meriden in the short term. He listed a couple of activities that he’d like to spend more time pursuing, including writing and his work as director of Christian education at Center Congregational Church.

There’s also his involvement with Builders Beyond Borders, which engages high school students in humanitarian efforts.
“The Y absorbs you, as John knows in the position he has,” Miller said. “So it’s a bit of a sacrifice; so this is a chance to get that time back.”

Miller said he’ll remain involved in the community. “I plan to continue to come into the Y,” he said. “We want people to have a sense that it’s going to be a comfortable transition.”

john12774
10-10-2007, 10:57 AM
Hmmmm...

Mayor and Brice Miller = best friends...

Mayor and John Benigni = Brothers...

John Benigni as new Exec. Dir. of YMCA = coincidence?

No national search for a executive position that pays over $70K??? His 15 years with the YMCA doesn't replace the qualifications needed for such a position. Let's just say the requirements were improvised because IT IS A circle of friends that scratch each other's back.

Tino3
10-10-2007, 04:40 PM
It seems as though 15 years WOULD give you enough experience and background to do the job well. I'm sure the board would have done a broader search if they felt there needed to be one.

Fit 2 Print
10-10-2007, 04:47 PM
Can you name one qualification he's lacking to do a first-class job for the YMCA?

john12774
10-10-2007, 05:20 PM
Having worked for the YMCA as a director, I can assure you that a position of Executive Director requires fiscal management, budgetary responsibilities, fund raising, volunteer work, staff development, property management, and YMCA directives including: YMCA Senior Director certification and YMCA of USA recognition. Also, prior years of experience in that position or related is usually preferred.

I am not saying he may or may not have all these qualifications, but I am willing to bet that the board improvised a bit because of his personal relationship with Bruce and Mark. Maybe his 15 years was pressure on Bruce? After wall, imagine overlooking your best friend's brother to succeed in your position?

Eastside Bill
10-10-2007, 08:42 PM
Besides the fact that John is the Mayor's brother, doesn't board president Jackie Fordiani work for the Mayor's office?

While John Benigni may be well qualified for the job, the impression is that it is not his qualifications that got him the job but his connections at city hall.

john12774
10-11-2007, 11:53 AM
Thank you Eastside Bill!!

janerose
10-11-2007, 05:23 PM
This is Meriden; it appears to me the people who volunteer on Committees and Boards of agencies and events in the City are pretty much the same people all the time; of course they know one another; with that knowledge comes trust. They get involved to help the City; it's image and the general good of the residents.
The choice of the new YMCA Director was made by a Board of Directors comprised of people who get involved; without outside influences; the decision while not unamious; was well thought out.
The Board of Directors has also changed; with new members who are committed to the YMCA, Meriden and doing what is right for this time in the YMCA's history.
We look for positive feedback; as a we approach a new era in the Y; so pull away from your computer and volunteer to do something positive in the City; try to stop thinking everything is corrupt or underhanded;

jma
10-11-2007, 05:41 PM
John may very well to a terrific job in his new position. Unfortunately, no one will ever know if he was hired because he was the right fit for the job, or the right family member for the job. It's unfair to both John and the citizens. It's not that the previous posts come from people with small minds. The fact is, there is far too much nepotism within the city, and it casts a cloud over most appointments. That said, I wish John well.

Eastside Bill
10-11-2007, 06:07 PM
This is Meriden; it appears to me the people who volunteer on Committees and Boards of agencies and events in the City are pretty much the same people all the time; of course they know one another; with that knowledge comes trust. They get involved to help the City; it's image and the general good of the residents.
The choice of the new YMCA Director was made by a Board of Directors comprised of people who get involved; without outside influences; the decision while not unamious; was well thought out.
The Board of Directors has also changed; with new members who are committed to the YMCA, Meriden and doing what is right for this time in the YMCA's history.
We look for positive feedback; as a we approach a new era in the Y; so pull away from your computer and volunteer to do something positive in the City; try to stop thinking everything is corrupt or underhanded;

I would take issue with your assumption that those in here do not volunteer and do something positive in the city. I can assure you that your assumption is incorrect. What I think most are saying is that no matter how talented John Benigini is, a cloud has been cast because of the pretty blatant political influences, be they internal or external.

collie
10-11-2007, 06:10 PM
Why is it that people like Jane Rose (is she a member of the YMCA board or what?) feel that people who offer criticism solely sit in front of their computers, whine and are NOT volunteering in the community? The appearance of nepotism is what people will talk about behind closed doors; better for that to be faced out in the open, if you ask me.

Fit 2 Print
10-12-2007, 04:28 PM
So, in Meriden, is it "Who" you know more than "What" you know?

john12774
10-12-2007, 06:27 PM
I think the last couple of years confirms this...

collie
10-13-2007, 04:58 PM
Wow, another article in the paper re the YMCA being on probation with its national organization for financial reasons! I have been a member of the YMCA Outdoor Center for years; John Benigni was running it. Every year it deteriorated - broken lawn chairs not replaced, no diving board for two years and showers completely shut off! I called the Health Dept. about the shut off showers due to health law concerns. At any rate, I wondered at the time why the Y wasn't fixing this stuff for its outdoor center members; God knows they charge enough for kids to go to camp there. The mayor will be recusing himself from discussions if the YMCA comes running to the city to bail them out of these "problems." Good thing the national YMCA is auditing them; it sounds like they need it.

Fit 2 Print
10-15-2007, 02:06 PM
Pardon the pun, but: is the YMCA awash in qualified candidates, or making a splash in the news by its decision-making?!

Eastside Bill
10-16-2007, 07:40 AM
It is disconcerting that the YMCA board rejected the advice of the national YMCA and did not conduct a national search but instead, handed the reins over to the Mayor's brother. That the board president also works for the Mayor's office (http://www.cityofmeriden.org/directory/default.asp?CMS_ModuleID=61) just adds to the impression that this may not have been the best call for the Y. One would have hoped that Fordiani would have recused herself because of the conflict of interest. While that may not be required by the YMCA board, it certainly would have made sense for her to step away from this particular decision. That said, may John Bengini rise to the occasion!

john12774
10-16-2007, 10:05 AM
If they(YMCA) honestly wanted to "save face" with the city residents, they could have held a national search. I don't know where they get their figures that search would cost $10,000+???

They could have placed an weekend ad in the Hartford Currant ($500-700)
They could have placed another ad in careerbuilder.com ($100-250)
YMCA of USA career website (Free)

Everyone is benefiting from Mayor's Mark's kindness, don't you think?

Fit 2 Print
10-16-2007, 05:32 PM
A more transparent process, from start to finish, would have helped to remove clouds of doubt, yes?